Greg's solar power comparison
Greg's diary
Photo index
Greg's home page
Network link stats
Greg's other links
Copyright information
Groogle

This page is an attempt to make sense of the quotations I have had for solar power in February/March 2019, mainly from Effective Electrical in Ballarat.

The quotes are really difficult to understand; I suspect that Tomas doesn't either. They also don't seem to match reality. In particular:

I'm left with the distinct impression that Tomas is having difficulty with his quotation software.

Date       Quotation       Panel       Average       Battery       Battery rating       Battery rating       Exported       Grid       "Solar used"       Inverter       Inverter       Price       Comments
      number       rating (kW)       output (kW)       type       (kWh, gross)       (kWh, net)       (kWh)       input (kWh)                   output       after rebates
8 February 2019             5.7       20.5       Tesla Powerwall 2       13.5       10.8                         Fronius       5.0 kW       18,245.00       Cola Solar
24 February 2019       423       10.8       42.9       LG Chem RESU 10 (2)       19.6       17.64       8       15       89%       Fronius 8.2-1/Selectronic SPMC482-AU       8.2 kW       27,246.30       conflicting inverter specs
24 February 2019       423       10.8       42.9       BYD B-Box Pro 13.8       13.8       12.42       9       17       87%       Selectronic SPMC482-AU       8.2 kW       23,883.60       The one I chose
15 March 2019       423       10.8       42.9       LG Chem RESU 10       9.8       8.82       9       17       87%       Selectronic SPMC482-AU       8.2 kW       27,246.30       Same as first 423, but only one battery!
15 March 2019       487       10.8       42.9       BYD B-Plus L 14                   8       16       87%       Selectronic SPMC482-AU       8.2 kW       28,786.30       Repeat of 423/2, $5000 more expensive; incomplete details
15 March 2019       498       10.8       42.9       BYD B-Plus H 6.4       6.4       6.4       12       22             Ingeteam SUN 1Play-6TL       6 kW       18,562.30       No "solar used"
21 March 2019       510       10.8       42.9       BYD B-Plus H 6.4 (2)       12.8       12.8       8       17       94%       Ingeteam SUN 1Play-6TL       6 kW       24,172.30
23 March 2019       498       10.8       42.9       BYD B-Plus H 6.4       6.4       6.4       12       22       91%       Ingeteam SUN 1Play-6TL       6 kW       18,562.30       Repeat of 15 March
23 March 2019       510       10.8       42.9       BYD B-Plus H 6.4 (2)       12.8       12.8       8       17       94%       Ingeteam SUN 1Play-6TL       6 kW       24,172.30       Repeat of 21 March
23 March 2019       423       10.8       42.9       BYD B-Box Pro 13.8       13.8       13.25       9       17       89%       Selectronic SPMC482-AU       8.2 kW       29,039.30       Same equipment as 24 February, $5,155/22% more expensive
23 March 2019       528       10.8       42.9       BYD B-Plus H 6.4 (3)       19.2       19.2       6       15       95%       Ingeteam SUN 1Play-6TL       6 kW       30,466.00       Missing important battery information

On the other hand, the only comparable quote that I received, from Cola Solar, was much more expensive. Compare it with quote 498 of 15 March: half the power, though nearly 70% more storage; would that ever charge up?


Greg's home page Greg's diary Greg's photos Copyright

Valid XHTML 1.0!

$Id: solar-power-comparison.php,v 1.2 2019/03/24 04:38:36 grog Exp $